Oklahoma City is home to many excellent insurance companies that provide a range of policies to meet the needs of individuals, families, and businesses in the area. Here is a look at 15 of the top-rated insurance companies in OKC based on customer reviews, salaries, number of local jobs, and company information.School News Portal
Finding the right insurance company in Oklahoma City can seem like a daunting task, with so many options to choose from. To make your search easier, we’ve compiled a list of OKC’s 15 best insurance companies across areas like auto, home, life, and health insurance. We evaluated each company on customer ratings, number of local jobs and salaries, years in business, financial strength, and community involvement. Whether you’re looking for a major national carrier or a local Oklahoma-based insurer, read on to see which companies stand out for quality, service and support in the OKC metro.
15 Best Insurance Companies OKC
1. State Farm
With a 4.5 rating across over 17,000 reviews, State Farm tops the list as the highest-rated insurance company in OKC. As the most prominent auto and home insurer in the U.S., State Farm has over 19,000 employees countrywide and has been in business since 1922. Policyholders can bundle home and auto insurance for discounts and also get coverage for renters, condos, motorcycles, boats, life, businesses and more. State Farm is known for local agents providing personalized service and support when you need it most. There are over 150 State Farm agent offices in the greater OKC metro.Insurance Companies OKC
Another highly rated national company, Allstate, has a strong presence in Oklahoma City with over 80 local agency offices. Allstate writes auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycles, and RV and boat insurance policies. They also provide life, business, retirement and financial products to protect OKC residents and businesses. Allstate has an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from A.M. Best and gets positive reviews from customers for affordable rates and experienced agents.
3. Liberty Mutual
With a strong national presence and over 65 OKC-area office locations, Liberty Mutual offers a wide range of insurance policies for auto, home, life, business and more. Employee benefits like health, dental, disability and retirement plans are also available from Liberty Mutual. Policyholders can bundle home and auto insurance for multi-policy discounts. Liberty Mutual has an A financial strength rating from A.M. Best and has been in business since 1912.
4. AAA Oklahoma (CSAA Insurance Group)
AAA Oklahoma provides AAA members in the metro area with CSAA home, auto, and life insurance products. Available coverage options include auto, homeowners, renters, condo, flood, identity protection, umbrella and valuable personal property. Policy discounts are offered for bundling home and auto coverage. AAA Oklahoma also provides travel, roadside assistance and DMV services for members. The company is rated A by A.M. Best and gets positive reviews for good value policies and experienced local agents.
Read Also: 15 Best Maritime Attorneys in Houston, USA
5. The Hartford
With an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best, The Hartford offers home, auto, business and more policies to protect OKC residents and business owners. Available coverages include homeowners, renters, auto, motorcycle, RV, condo, boat, umbrella, and business insurance. The Hartford website and agents provide 24/7 service and support resources like risk management tools, safety tips, and insurance education. Discounts are offered on bundled policies. Founded in 1810, The Hartford has a strong reputation for claims service and customer satisfaction.
Known for innovative options like the Name Your Price tool and Snapshot safe driver program, Progressive provides auto, motorcycle, homeowners, and other insurance policies to OKC-area customers. You can get free quotes online or by contacting local independent agents. Progressive writes auto insurance in all 50 states with an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from A.M. Best. Policy add-ons like custom parts/equipment value, rideshare coverage, and roadside assistance are available.
7. American Income Life (AIL)
Providing supplemental health and life insurance products in OKC for over 50 years, American Income Life has an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best. AIL offers supplemental and accidental death policies, mortgage protection, and annuities to union members and working families. An AIL agent contacts interested customers to discuss coverage options and provide a custom-tailored recommendation. Many policyholders give positive feedback on AIL’s quick claims payments and helpful agents.
8. American Fidelity Assurance
Headquartered in Oklahoma City, American Fidelity provides supplemental health and life coverage, including disability income, cancer, accident, critical illness and life insurance. American Fidelity has an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best and is among the Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For. Products are available to individuals and employer groups with custom-designed portfolios. Knowledgeable agents provide good service and competitive rates.
9. Arthur J. Gallagher
Operating in OKC for over 85 years, Gallagher is one of the area’s largest insurance brokerages, providing commercial insurance and risk management. Gallagher brokers specialize in construction, energy, financial institutions, healthcare, manufacturing, and public entities. In addition to business insurance, Gallagher also offers employee benefits, retirement, and personal insurance. The company is known for industry expertise, strong carrier relationships and exceptional local service.
10. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma
With over 80 years in Oklahoma, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma provides health, dental, life and disability insurance. BCBS health plans include PPO, HMO, Medicare Advantage and FEP. OKC customers give positive feedback on the affordability, large provider network, and service from BCBS agents and representatives. The company has an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from A.M. Best.
Read Also: 15 Best Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
Chubb is a leading commercial property and casualty insurer that has been in business for over 130 years. In the OKC metro, Chubb provides insurance for middle market companies, large corporations, specialized industry sectors, and high net worth individuals. Available coverages include property, casualty, environmental, professional liability, surety, marine, and more. Chubb has strong financial ratings and a global underwriting network.
12. CNA Insurance
Serving businesses in Oklahoma City for over 60 years, CNA specializes in commercial property/casualty insurance and risk management solutions. CNA protects OKC businesses against risks including property damage, lawsuits, cyber attacks, and business interruption. Additional services like risk control and claim support are provided by local CNA representatives. CNA has an A rating for financial strength from A.M. Best.
Read Also: UW Academic Calendar 2022-2023
13. Farmers Insurance
With availability 24/7, Farmers Insurance provides OKC customers with competitively priced coverage for auto, homeowners, business, life, renters, condo, motorcycle and more. Policyholders can access claims services and make payments through the Farmers app and online portal. An A rating from A.M. Best speaks to Farmers’ strong financial position and ability to pay claims. Discounts are offered when you bundle home/auto or add extra safety features.
14. Securian Financial Group
Based in Minnesota and operating in OKC for over 100 years, Securian Financial offers insurance and investment solutions, including life, annuities, employee benefits, business, and more. They provide insurance products to individuals and businesses through independent agents and financial institutions. Securian has solid financial ratings and continues the tradition of its predecessor, Bankers Life, which was founded in 1879.
15. Shelter Insurance
Founded in 1946 and headquartered in Columbia, Missouri, Shelter Insurance operates over 25 agencies in the greater OKC area. Shelter Insurance agents provide auto, home, business, farm, life, and speciality insurance tailored to be simple, honest, and helpful. Claims are handled locally by Shelter agents, with 97% satisfaction ratings. Shelter Insurance has an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best.
Read Also: UIUC Academic Calendar 2022-2023
Finding the right insurance company in OKC starts with understanding your coverage needs, budget, and priorities. We hope this list of highly-rated insurers provides a useful starting point to compare options. Look for an insurer that offers the types of policies you need, has strong financial ratings, and provides good local customer service. With the insurance carriers featured here, Oklahoma City residents and businesses can feel confident in finding protection that fits their unique needs.